Punjab politics and Sharifs

Mazhar Abbas

Punjab, historically, lacks in producing leaders of national stature, which often come from the
smaller provinces. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, despite being from Sindh, had emerged as the most
prominent leader of Punjab. Sharifs entry into politics took place to counter the myth of
Bhuttos and the PPP, with a difference that Sharifs belong to Punjab. Now, for the first time
after 30 years, Sharifs have a challenger from within Punjab, Imran Khan, the man from

While Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) is also fighting hard to regain Punjab and to pose itself as
the real opposition than Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), it still appears as if the next elections
would be quite challenging in the battle of Punjab.

Prior to Bhutto, the Punjab’s political leadership by and large remained proxy of the establi-
shment while the strong leadership came from the then Bengal or East Pakistan, followed by
leaders from the then North-West Frontier Province (NWFP) or Balochistan, like Khan Abdul
Wali Khan, Maulana Mufti Mahmood, Sardar Attaullah Mengal, Mir Ghous Bux Bizenjo etc.

Pakistan Muslim League (PML), after the death of Quaid-e-Azam and Liaquat Ali Khan, divided
into different factions as the leaders from Punjab could not counter the Bengali leadership of
Muslim League like Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy.

What happened from 1948 to 1958 was disastrous for Pakistan and political failures, combined
with civil-military bureaucracy conspiracy, led to the imposition of the first martial law in 1958,
which through One Unit, laid the foundation of what happened in 1971.

When Mohtarma Fatima Jinnah challenged Ayub Khan in the Presidential election, she could
only won from Karachi and Dhaka, while Punjab went with Ayub.

The 1970 elections was the turning point and Bhutto, after leaving Ayub’s cabinet, made his
party, the PPP, which became the most popular party of Punjab within three years (1967-
1970). He used nationalistic and anti-India slogan beside “Roti, Kapra and Makan”.

In the aftermath of break-up of Pakistan, Punjab’s political importance became the decisive
factor in ruling Islamabad, which is still the key factor.

The Bhutto rule ended with the imposition of a martial law on July 5, 1977. Zia promised
elections in 90 days, without knowing Bhutto was still popular in Sindh and Punjab, which
led to election postponement. Later, Bhutto was hanged in a controversial trial and Zia
never faced any serious challenge till his death in a plane crash on August 17, 1988.

In the post-Bhutto era, Punjab politics has revolved around Sharifs even when they were
not in power. Nawaz Sharif created history in 2013 when he became the prime minister
for the third time. While the duo – Nawaz and Shahbaz – rarely lost Punjab since 1985,
will they be lucky this time in the aftermath of Panama Papers and the challenger from
Mianwali, Imran Khan.

Historically, the remnant of the then Zia establishment, Sharif’s political career started
with Tehrik-e-Istaqlal, which under the leadership of Air Marshal (retired) Asghar Khan
was launched as an alternative to Bhutto and the PPP, to make inroads into Punjab.

Zia wanted someone from Punjab, preferably from central Punjab, who could not only
counter the PPP but also emerge as a national leader. Zia knew that even after Bhutto’s
hanging, his widow and daughter could create problems in his future game-plan.

Baray Mian Sahib was not interested in politics nor wanted his sons to join politics. But,
he was anti-Bhutto because his factories had been nationalised by him during the PPP
government. The issue was exploited by Zia, and a senior PPP leader revealed an
interesting story of Nawaz Sharif’s entry into politics, first through the establishment
and later on his own.

An unimpeachable PML source disclosed that Mian Nawaz Sharif, for the first time, was
offered Ministry in Zia’s cabinet while he was the finance secretary of Tehrik-e-Istaqlal.
But, the late Majeed Nizami, who convinced Mian Sharif to play a role in politics as
Punjab lacked political leadership and as a businessman he could become a force
against feudal-lords.

“One day Mr Wazir Ali, father of Shahnaz Wazir Ali, who was Tehrik-e-Istaqlal central
leader, was sitting with Mian Sharif. Nawaz Sharif entered the room and Wazir Ali told
him about the offer. He (Wazir) advised Nawaz not to join him as elections are due,”
source said, adding that Sharif replied that he did see elections in near future.

“Few days later, Mian Sahib took the oath as sports minister,” source said.

Later, the establishment build Sharif’s political image but since political sentiments
were high after Bhutto’s execution and Bhutto ladies were in exile, a Sindhi politician,
Mohammad Khan Junejo was made the prime minister after non-party based elections.

Even a faction of Pakistanis left and the progressives also backed Sharif as they believed
that through industrialization, feudalism would get weaker and pave the way for
progressive politics and strengthen democracy.

Junejo lost Zia’s confidence after Geneva Accord, and the establishment got him sacked.
This paved the way for Sharif to get control over Muslim League. It paid off with the
support of General Zia and former ISI chief, Lt-Gen Hameed Gul.

Zia first held referendum in 1984 to get some legitimacy and later elections on non-party
basis, in a bid to keep the PPP out of politics and secondly to have weak democratic

When Benazir decided to end her exile, Zia never thought she would get such a reception.
It scared both Zia and Gul, and this led to the formation of Islami Jamoohri Ittehad (IJI)
led by Nawaz Sharif.

After 1988, Sharifs never looked back and till 1990, Sharifs and the establishment were
hand-in-glove against the PPP, to dissolve Bhutto’s myth. He was pitched against Benazir
Bhutto as a national leader while he was the Punjab chief minister. Later, he was made
President of the IJI, the brainchild of former ISI chief, Gen Hameed Gul.The first
differences between Sharif and the establishment appeared when he did not back one
of his mentors General Gul as the army chief.

However, credit goes to Sharif that he turned the PML, a traditionally pro-establishment
party, into a political party and during nine years of General Musharraf resisted the
establishment pressure.

Being a politician from Punjab, luck also favoured him time and again. But, experience
and anti-establishment stance during Musharraf’s era also brought him and Benazir
closer to an extent that they signed historic the Charter of Democracy in 2006.

Sharif was also lucky that in 1993 Supreme Court restored his government, which was
dismissed on corruption charges, but in 1990 and 1996, it did not restore the PPP
government sacked on the same charges. However, he remained unlucky that in 2001,
the SC in Zafar Ali Shah case gave legitimacy to Musharraf’s coup.

Mian Sahib practically went unchallenged particularly in Punjab, before the rise of the
man from Mianwali. It took him 20 years to get recognition as a national leader and
that too from Punjab, despite having huge Pashtun following.

How far Imran Khan-led Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf would make a dent in the strong
constituency of powerful Sharifs inside Punjab, depends on the outcome of the Panama
leaks. However, some senior PML-N leaders believe that even if decision goes against
them, the party will sweep the polls and that too, through, Sharifs.

“In 2008 elections, when Mian Sahib was disqualified, we fought and won Punjab on
Mian Sahib’s photograph. I am sure we will win the legal battle but are ready to accept
any decision of the Supreme Court, and rest assured that the PML would not lose
Punjab,” a senior PML-N leader told this writer on condition of anonymity.

National politics has now completely switched to Punjab, particularly after the assass-
ination of Benazir Bhutto in 2007, and the PPP could not regain Punjab. In fact in
2013, it completely lost the big province in a most humiliating manner.

Nevertheless, the rise of Imran Khan is considered by many political pundits as a
good omen for Pakistan, for different reasons. In the absence of Benazir, the country
needed an alternative political leader and ideally, someone from Punjab or at least
having strong political base in Punjab, as it determines who would rule Pakistan.

Imran grabbed the political opportunity and exploited the PPP’s bad governance and
Sharif’s corruption as burning issues. With his hero image and charisma, beside a tag
of an untested leader with Lahore as his political base, helped him a great deal. Thus,
the province which historically lacked in producing leaders of national stature now
has a contest among the two prominent leaders from Lahore and Mianwali.

Imran’s rise came as a result of continuity of democracy and if it continues, it may
also break the strong biradri system in the province.

The writer is a senior columnist and analyst of Geo, The News and Jang. —Twitter:

Source: https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/172381-Punjab-politics-and-Sharifs
December 17, 2016

web counter
Thank You!

Send email to nazeerkahut@punjabics.com with questions, comment or suggestions

Punjabics is a literary, non-profit and non-Political, non-affiliated organization

Punjabics.com @ Copyright 2008 - 2018 Punjabics.Com All Rights Reserved

Website Design & SEO by Webpagetime.com